Journal
Thanksgiving With a New Baby and Everyone's Opinions
The baby will be passed around the table. So will the opinions.
This year Thanksgiving falls on November 26, and for many new mothers it is the first time the whole family is in one room with the baby. It is also the first time you are a mother in front of the people who raised you, and the people who raised your partner.
Your aunt wonders aloud whether the baby is getting enough to eat. Your father-in-law says all that holding will spoil the baby. Someone repeats sleep advice from thirty years ago with complete confidence. Your mother watches you change a diaper and says nothing, which somehow says more.
Most of it is love with poor timing. Some of it is older than the baby, and your body usually knows which is which before you do.
Where the Day Gets Hard
- 01
Questions about feeding that are really verdicts, whether you are nursing, pumping, using formula or some of each
- 02
Running commentary on sleep from people who will not be up with the baby at 2am
- 03
The baby going from lap to lap while you track every pair of hands
- 04
Being asked at the table how the birth went
- 05
Being handed your old part in the family the moment you walk in, as if the baby changed nothing
- 06
A visit that runs two hours past the point you were done, because nobody wants to be the one to end it
- 07
Guilt for wanting to go home early on a day that is supposed to be about gratitude
Why It Lands So Hard This Year
New motherhood comes with a confidence that is still being built, mostly at night and mostly alone. A comment you would shrug off in any other year can feel like a ruling on whether you are doing this right.
Family advice also carries history. When a parent tells you how it should be done, they are often defending how they did it, which is why disagreeing can feel like an accusation to both of you. And if disagreeing with a parent was never safe in your house, saying no at their table can feel as risky now as it did when you were small.
Holding Your Ground, Kindly
- 01
Settle the plan with your partner before you go: how long you will stay, who holds the baby, and the signal that means it is time to leave. Then let your partner be the one who says it.
- 02
Choose one sentence and use it as often as you need. 'Thanks, we have a plan that is working for us' does not invite a debate.
- 03
Let the pediatrician be the authority. 'Our pediatrician wants us to do it this way' closes more conversations than any argument.
- 04
Use feedings and naps as exits. A quiet room with the baby is a break nobody will question.
- 05
Decide in advance which comments you will let pass. Not every remark needs an answer, and you do not have to win.
You can be warm and still be clear. 'We love you, and we are heading home at four' is both.
When It Is About More Than One Dinner
If you have been dreading the day for weeks, if one remark from your mother can undo you for the rest of the weekend, or if becoming a mother has stirred up things about your own childhood you thought were long settled, that is worth bringing to therapy.
When I work with this, Internal Family Systems is often where we start. The part of you that goes quiet at that table is usually much younger than the woman holding the baby, and it can be met directly instead of being overruled every holiday. We can also work on the practical side: what you want next year to look like, and what you are willing to say to get there.
Sessions are in person in Prince George or by telehealth anywhere in Virginia.
If You Are Already Bracing for the Holiday
The consultation is free and it is only a conversation. Fifteen minutes, no pressure, and you decide afterward.